RSS Feed

Vanilla Sugar Cookies Made With Unexpected Substitutions

Cookies With Sprinkles

Sugar Cookies With Sprinkles

These cookies gave me a huge lesson in baking substitutions. They are really good. I think they shouldn’t taste this good, given all my substitutions, but I was pleasantly surprised.

First of all, I only need my food to be soy and milk-free. But this recipe also happens to be vegan as well as egg-free, nut-free, and gluten-free too. I used the recipe on the back of the Bob’s Red Mill Coconut Flour bag to make them. I’ve included the recipe at the end of this post, for those interested.

This recipe called for interesting ingredients. I have never baked with ingredients such as coconut flour, brown rice flour, and potato starch.

Bob's Red Mill Potato Starch, Coconut Flour, and Brown Rice Flour

Bob's Red Mill Potato Starch, Coconut Flour, and Brown Rice Flour

Instead of butter, I used Spectrum Butter Flavor Shortening (Palm Oil).

Spectrum Butter Flavor Shortening (Palm Oil)

Spectrum Butter Flavor Shortening (Palm Oil)

My son and I used the electric beater on the sugar and palm oil shortening.

Fun With the Electric Mixer

Fun With the Electric Mixer

It didn’t produce a creamy mixture that butter would have.

I used Vanilla Coconut Milk instead of the Soy Milk ingredient. Coconut milk is something my toddler and I only discovered this week, and it is has been a huge hit. My son likes it in his cereal. I like it with my protein drinks.

So Delicious Vanilla Coconut Milk

So Delicious Vanilla Coconut Milk

I found some sprinkles that looked interesting (gluten-free Sprinkelz). The sprinkles are not as colorful in actuality as they are on the picture of the box (see the first cookie picture at the top of this post).

Sprinkelz

Sprinkelz

By the way, I added Enjoy Life Semi-Sweet Chocolate Mini Chips (dairy, nut, & soy free!) to the top of some of the cookies when they came out of the oven. Of course, my son just picked them off instead of eating the cookie.

We Added Mini Chocolate Chips to The Top of Some of the Warming Cookies

We Added Mini Chocolate Chips to The Top of Some of the Warming Cookies

Enjoy Life Mini Chips - Dairy, Nut, & Soy Free

Enjoy Life Mini Chips - Dairy, Nut, & Soy Free

We also experimented with adding strawberry jelly on some of the cookies. Again, he couldn’t help himself. I let him dip his finger into the cookie…that was HIS cookie now.

All-in-all, I like the substitutions. My only complaint is the palm oil leaves a slight aftertaste — I didn’t notice it with yesterday’s batch but I especially noticed it when eating the cookies with the jelly on it. I might try using coconut spread next time.
So, what’s my conclusion about all these substitutions? I’m going to keep making them in other recipes. It’s my fun new journey in the kitchen!

Vanilla Sugar Cookies

1 cup Sugar

1/2 cup Butter (I used Palm Oil Shortening instead)

1/3 cup Soymilk (I used Coconut Milk instead)

2 tsp. Vanilla

3/4 cup White Rice Flour (I used Brown Rice Flour)

1/3 cup Coconut Flour

2 Tbsp. Potato Starch

1/2 tsp. Baking Powder

1/2 tsp. Baking Soda

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Cream together shortening and sugar with an electric mixer and beat two minutes. Add vanilla and milk (coconut milk) and beat for an additional minute. In a separate bowl, mix together dry ingredients. Add dry mix to wet ingredients and briefly mix, then add the almonds. Continue mixing until just blended. The batter should have a moist and fluffy consistency. Place by rounded tablespoon on greased cookie sheet (actually, I didn’t need to grease the sheet when using the palm oil shortening) and bake 10-12 minutes (I needed close to 13 minutes). Makes 24 cookies.

One response »

  1. I’m allergic to soy and dairy too (and, sadly, white potatoes, beef, cashew, coconut, white grapes and some other things. I’ve tried vegan restaurants, but everything is made of soy, coconut or cashew. Anyway, I want to find a way to share what I find. Do you post on Facebook too? FYI … chipotle is completely soy free except for the flour tortillas. If you think some dairy snuck into the guacamole or salsas, they’ll grab a new container for you (and they’re super nice about it). Which Wich, the sandwich company, has soy free breads and sauces and an easy to read allergen guide on line (as does Chipotle). Pasadena Sandwich Company only uses olive oil (and they use an olive oil that is actually PURE, versus the crap imports that are mostly laced with cheap soybean oil) and they have one bread that is soy free. I found a palm oil shortening at Whole Foods and it’s $3 less expensive than the same item at Ralph’s (I thought Whole Foods was ALWAYS more expensive). Soledad Goats in Mojave comes to a lot of the farmers markets. They don’t have milk, but their fresh cheeses are incredible. Sprouts carries goat milk, goat buttermilk, and goat butter. The butter is $5 for a half pound vs. $9 at Whole Foods. Whole Foods has goat ice cream that is ridiculously creamy and good, and would be addictive if not so expensive ($7 pint). There is a variety of flavors. I’ve also found a few chocolate sources. Dave and Busters is awesome! Their allergy menu is a page for each allergy, so not helpful for people with multiple allergies, BUT their BBQ sauce is soy and dairy free and the chef will come to your table and figure out a meal. I had pork ribs and zucchini and new potatoes grilled. Really good.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: